Storage and Retrieval Codes in Star Product PIR Schemes with Colluding Servers

Private information retrieval (PIR) schemes (with or without colluding servers) have been proposed for realistic coded distributed data storage systems. Star product PIR schemes with colluding servers for general coded distributed storage system were constructed over general finite fields by R. Freij-Hollanti, O. W. Gnilke, C. Hollanti and A. Karpuk in 2017. These star product PIR schemes with colluding servers are suitable for the storage of files over small fields and can be constructed for coded distributed storage system with large number of servers. In this paper for an efficient storage code, the problem to find good retrieval codes is considered. In general if the storage code is a binary Reed-Muller code the retrieval code needs not to be a binary Reed-Muller code in general. It is proved that when the storage code contains some special codewords, nonzero retrieval rate star product PIR schemes with colluding servers can only protect against small number of colluding servers. We also give examples to show that when the storage code is a good cyclic code, the best choice of the retrieval code is not cyclic in general. Therefore in the design of star product PIR schemes with colluding servers, the scheme with the storage code and the retrieval code in the same family of algebraic codes is not always efficient.