The Adversary Bound Revisited: From Optimal Query Algorithms to Optimal Control

This note complements the upcoming paper "One-Way Ticket to Las Vegas and the Quantum Adversary" by Belovs and Yolcu, to be presented at QIP 2023. I develop the ideas behind the adversary bound - universal algorithm duality therein in a different form, using the same perspective as Barnum-Saks-Szegedy in which query algorithms are defined as sequences of feasible reduced density matrices rather than sequences of unitaries. This form may be faster to understand for a general quantum information audience: It avoids defining the "unidirectional relative $\gamma_{2}$-bound" and relating it to query algorithms explicitly. This proof is also more general because the lower bound (and universal query algorithm) apply to a class of optimal control problems rather than just query problems. That is in addition to the advantages to be discussed in Belovs-Yolcu, namely the more elementary algorithm and correctness proof that avoids phase estimation and spectral analysis, allows for limited treatment of noise, and removes another $\Theta(\log(1/\epsilon))$ factor from the runtime compared to the previous discrete-time algorithm.