Deep artificial neural networks (ANNs) play a major role in modeling the visual pathways of primate and rodent. However, they highly simplify the computational properties of neurons compared to their biological counterparts. Instead, Spiking Neural Networks (SNNs) are more biologically plausible models since spiking neurons encode information with time sequences of spikes, just like biological neurons do. However, there is a lack of studies on visual pathways with deep SNNs models. In this study, we model the visual cortex with deep SNNs for the first time, and also with a wide range of state-of-the-art deep CNNs and ViTs for comparison. Using three similarity metrics, we conduct neural representation similarity experiments on three neural datasets collected from two species under three types of stimuli. Based on extensive similarity analyses, we further investigate the functional hierarchy and mechanisms across species. Almost all similarity scores of SNNs are higher than their counterparts of CNNs with an average of 6.6%. Depths of the layers with the highest similarity scores exhibit little differences across mouse cortical regions, but vary significantly across macaque regions, suggesting that the visual processing structure of mice is more regionally homogeneous than that of macaques. Besides, the multi-branch structures observed in some top mouse brain-like neural networks provide computational evidence of parallel processing streams in mice, and the different performance in fitting macaque neural representations under different stimuli exhibits the functional specialization of information processing in macaques. Taken together, our study demonstrates that SNNs could serve as promising candidates to better model and explain the functional hierarchy and mechanisms of the visual system.
翻译:深度人工神经网络在建模灵长类动物和啮齿类动物的视觉通路方面扮演着重要角色。然而,相比其生物学对应物,它们高度简化了神经元的计算特性。而脉冲神经网络(SNNs)则是更生物学可行的模型,因为脉冲神经元像生物神经元一样通过时间序列编码信息。然而,缺乏关于视觉通路深度SNN模型的研究。在本研究中,我们第一次使用深度SNN对视觉皮层进行建模,并且使用一系列最先进的深度CNN和ViT进行比较。使用三个相似性度量指标,在两个物种三种刺激类型下收集了三个神经数据集进行神经表示相似性实验。基于广泛的相似性分析,我们进一步研究了跨物种的功能层次和机制。几乎所有SNN的相似性得分都高于它们的CNN对应物,平均高出6.6%。具有最高相似性分数的层的深度在老鼠皮层区域间几乎不存在差异,但在猕猴区域间存在显着差异,表明老鼠视觉处理结构比猕猴更为区域性均质。此外,一些与老鼠大脑类似的神经网络中观察到的多分支结构为老鼠中的并行处理流提供了计算证据,而在不同刺激下适应猕猴神经表示的不同性能则展示了猕猴信息处理的功能专门化。综上所述,我们的研究表明,SNN将成为更好地建立和解释视觉系统功能层次和机制的有前途的候选方法。