Geometric deep learning can find representations that are optimal for a given task and therefore improve the performance over pre-defined representations. While current work has mainly focused on point representations, meshes also contain connectivity information and are therefore a more comprehensive characterization of the underlying anatomical surface. In this work, we evaluate four recent geometric deep learning approaches that operate on mesh representations. These approaches can be grouped into template-free and template-based approaches, where the template-based methods need a more elaborate pre-processing step with the definition of a common reference template and correspondences. We compare the different networks for the prediction of Alzheimer's disease based on the meshes of the hippocampus. Our results show advantages for template-based methods in terms of accuracy, number of learnable parameters, and training speed. While the template creation may be limiting for some applications, neuroimaging has a long history of building templates with automated tools readily available. Overall, working with meshes is more involved than working with simplistic point clouds, but they also offer new avenues for designing geometric deep learning architectures.
翻译:虽然目前的工作主要侧重于点表征,但缩略语也包含连接信息,因此是基础解剖表面的更全面特征。在这项工作中,我们评估了最近四个在网状表征上运作的几何深学习方法。这些方法可以归为无模板和基于模板的方法,基于模板的方法需要有一个更精细的预处理步骤来界定共同参考模板和通信。我们比较了基于河马坎普斯网模的预测阿尔茨海默氏病的不同网络。我们的结果显示基于模板的方法在准确性、可学习参数数量和培训速度方面的优势。虽然模板的创建可能对某些应用有限制,但神经成像具有长期的建立模板的历史,有可用的自动工具。总体而言,与模具合作比与简单点云和通信合作要多,但它们也为设计深层的几何学结构提供了新的途径。