Disentangled的假设的探讨

2018 年 12 月 10 日 CreateAMind
Disentangled的假设的探讨

Challenging Common Assumptions in the Unsupervised Learning of Disentangled Representations

Francesco Locatello, Stefan Bauer, Mario Lucic, Sylvain Gelly, Bernhard Schölkopf, Olivier Bachem

(Submitted on 29 Nov 2018 (v1), last revised 2 Dec 2018 (this version, v2))

In recent years, the interest in unsupervised learning of disentangled representations has significantly increased. The key assumption is that real-world data is generated by a few explanatory factors of variation and that these factors can be recovered by unsupervised learning algorithms. A large number of unsupervised learning approaches based on auto-encoding and quantitative evaluation metrics of disentanglement have been proposed; yet, the efficacy of the proposed approaches and utility of proposed notions of disentanglement has not been challenged in prior work. In this paper, we provide a sober look on recent progress in the field and challenge some common assumptions. 
We first theoretically show that the unsupervised learning of disentangled representations is fundamentally impossible without inductive biases on both the models and the data. Then, we train more than 12000 models covering the six most prominent methods, and evaluate them across six disentanglement metrics in a reproducible large-scale experimental study on seven different data sets. On the positive side, we observe that different methods successfully enforce properties "encouraged" by the corresponding losses. On the negative side, we observe in our study that well-disentangled models seemingly cannot be identified without access to ground-truth labels even if we are allowed to transfer hyperparameters across data sets. Furthermore, increased disentanglement does not seem to lead to a decreased sample complexity of learning for downstream tasks. 
These results suggest that future work on disentanglement learning should be explicit about the role of inductive biases and (implicit) supervision, investigate concrete benefits of enforcing disentanglement of the learned representations, and consider a reproducible experimental setup covering several data sets




Our contributions. The original motivation of this work was to provide a neutral large-scale study that benchmarks different unsupervised disentanglement methods and metrics on a wide set of data sets in a fair, reproducible experimental set up. However, the empirical evidence led us to instead challenge many commonly held assumptions in this field. Our key contributions can be summarized as follows: • We theoretically prove that (perhaps unsurprisingly) the unsupervised learning of disentangled representations is fundamentally impossible without inductive biases both on the considered learning approaches and the data sets. • We investigate current approaches and their inductive biases in a reproducible1 large-scale experimental study with a sound experimental protocol for unsupervised disentanglement learning. We implement from scratch six recent unsupervised disentanglement learning methods as well as six disentanglement measures and train more than 12 000 models on seven data sets. • We evaluate our experimental results and challenge many common assumptions in unsupervised disentanglement learning: (i) While all considered methods prove effective at ensuring that the individual dimensions of the aggregated posterior (which is sampled) are not correlated, only one method also consistently ensures that the individual dimensions of the representation (which is taken to be the mean) are not correlated. (ii) We do not find any evidence that the considered models can be used to reliably learn disentangled representations in an unsupervised manner as random seeds and hyperparameters seem to matter more than the model choice. Furthermore, good trained models seemingly cannot be identified without access to ground-truth labels even if we are allowed to transfer good hyperparameter values across data sets. (iii) For the considered models and data sets, we cannot validate the assumption that disentanglement is useful for downstream tasks, for example through a decreased sample complexity of learning. • Based on these empirical evidence, we suggest three critical areas of further research: (i) The role of inductive biases and implicit and explicit supervision should be made explicit: unsupervised model selection persists as a key question. (ii) The concrete practical benefits of enforcing a specific notion of disentanglement of the learned representations should be demonstrated. (iii) Experiments should be conducted in a reproducible experimental setup on data sets of varying degrees of difficulty.





登录查看更多
8

相关内容

现实生活中常常会有这样的问题:缺乏足够的先验知识,因此难以人工标注类别或进行人工类别标注的成本太高。很自然地,我们希望计算机能代我们完成这些工作,或至少提供一些帮助。根据类别未知(没有被标记)的训练样本解决模式识别中的各种问题,称之为无监督学习

Over the past few years, we have seen fundamental breakthroughs in core problems in machine learning, largely driven by advances in deep neural networks. At the same time, the amount of data collected in a wide array of scientific domains is dramatically increasing in both size and complexity. Taken together, this suggests many exciting opportunities for deep learning applications in scientific settings. But a significant challenge to this is simply knowing where to start. The sheer breadth and diversity of different deep learning techniques makes it difficult to determine what scientific problems might be most amenable to these methods, or which specific combination of methods might offer the most promising first approach. In this survey, we focus on addressing this central issue, providing an overview of many widely used deep learning models, spanning visual, sequential and graph structured data, associated tasks and different training methods, along with techniques to use deep learning with less data and better interpret these complex models --- two central considerations for many scientific use cases. We also include overviews of the full design process, implementation tips, and links to a plethora of tutorials, research summaries and open-sourced deep learning pipelines and pretrained models, developed by the community. We hope that this survey will help accelerate the use of deep learning across different scientific domains.

0
27
下载
预览

Reinforcement learning is one of the core components in designing an artificial intelligent system emphasizing real-time response. Reinforcement learning influences the system to take actions within an arbitrary environment either having previous knowledge about the environment model or not. In this paper, we present a comprehensive study on Reinforcement Learning focusing on various dimensions including challenges, the recent development of different state-of-the-art techniques, and future directions. The fundamental objective of this paper is to provide a framework for the presentation of available methods of reinforcement learning that is informative enough and simple to follow for the new researchers and academics in this domain considering the latest concerns. First, we illustrated the core techniques of reinforcement learning in an easily understandable and comparable way. Finally, we analyzed and depicted the recent developments in reinforcement learning approaches. My analysis pointed out that most of the models focused on tuning policy values rather than tuning other things in a particular state of reasoning.

0
55
下载
预览

User behavior data in recommender systems are driven by the complex interactions of many latent factors behind the users' decision making processes. The factors are highly entangled, and may range from high-level ones that govern user intentions, to low-level ones that characterize a user's preference when executing an intention. Learning representations that uncover and disentangle these latent factors can bring enhanced robustness, interpretability, and controllability. However, learning such disentangled representations from user behavior is challenging, and remains largely neglected by the existing literature. In this paper, we present the MACRo-mIcro Disentangled Variational Auto-Encoder (MacridVAE) for learning disentangled representations from user behavior. Our approach achieves macro disentanglement by inferring the high-level concepts associated with user intentions (e.g., to buy a shirt or a cellphone), while capturing the preference of a user regarding the different concepts separately. A micro-disentanglement regularizer, stemming from an information-theoretic interpretation of VAEs, then forces each dimension of the representations to independently reflect an isolated low-level factor (e.g., the size or the color of a shirt). Empirical results show that our approach can achieve substantial improvement over the state-of-the-art baselines. We further demonstrate that the learned representations are interpretable and controllable, which can potentially lead to a new paradigm for recommendation where users are given fine-grained control over targeted aspects of the recommendation lists.

0
6
下载
预览

Knowledge distillation is typically conducted by training a small model (the student) to mimic a large and cumbersome model (the teacher). The idea is to compress the knowledge from the teacher by using its output probabilities as soft-labels to optimize the student. However, when the teacher is considerably large, there is no guarantee that the internal knowledge of the teacher will be transferred into the student; even if the student closely matches the soft-labels, its internal representations may be considerably different. This internal mismatch can undermine the generalization capabilities originally intended to be transferred from the teacher to the student. In this paper, we propose to distill the internal representations of a large model such as BERT into a simplified version of it. We formulate two ways to distill such representations and various algorithms to conduct the distillation. We experiment with datasets from the GLUE benchmark and consistently show that adding knowledge distillation from internal representations is a more powerful method than only using soft-label distillation.

0
4
下载
预览

Small data challenges have emerged in many learning problems, since the success of deep neural networks often relies on the availability of a huge amount of labeled data that is expensive to collect. To address it, many efforts have been made on training complex models with small data in an unsupervised and semi-supervised fashion. In this paper, we will review the recent progresses on these two major categories of methods. A wide spectrum of small data models will be categorized in a big picture, where we will show how they interplay with each other to motivate explorations of new ideas. We will review the criteria of learning the transformation equivariant, disentangled, self-supervised and semi-supervised representations, which underpin the foundations of recent developments. Many instantiations of unsupervised and semi-supervised generative models have been developed on the basis of these criteria, greatly expanding the territory of existing autoencoders, generative adversarial nets (GANs) and other deep networks by exploring the distribution of unlabeled data for more powerful representations. While we focus on the unsupervised and semi-supervised methods, we will also provide a broader review of other emerging topics, from unsupervised and semi-supervised domain adaptation to the fundamental roles of transformation equivariance and invariance in training a wide spectrum of deep networks. It is impossible for us to write an exclusive encyclopedia to include all related works. Instead, we aim at exploring the main ideas, principles and methods in this area to reveal where we are heading on the journey towards addressing the small data challenges in this big data era.

0
70
下载
预览

We present a novel framework for the automatic discovery and recognition of motion primitives in videos of human activities. Given the 3D pose of a human in a video, human motion primitives are discovered by optimizing the `motion flux', a quantity which captures the motion variation of a group of skeletal joints. A normalization of the primitives is proposed in order to make them invariant with respect to a subject anatomical variations and data sampling rate. The discovered primitives are unknown and unlabeled and are unsupervisedly collected into classes via a hierarchical non-parametric Bayes mixture model. Once classes are determined and labeled they are further analyzed for establishing models for recognizing discovered primitives. Each primitive model is defined by a set of learned parameters. Given new video data and given the estimated pose of the subject appearing on the video, the motion is segmented into primitives, which are recognized with a probability given according to the parameters of the learned models. Using our framework we build a publicly available dataset of human motion primitives, using sequences taken from well-known motion capture datasets. We expect that our framework, by providing an objective way for discovering and categorizing human motion, will be a useful tool in numerous research fields including video analysis, human inspired motion generation, learning by demonstration, intuitive human-robot interaction, and human behavior analysis.

0
4
下载
预览

Image-to-image translation aims to learn the mapping between two visual domains. There are two main challenges for many applications: 1) the lack of aligned training pairs and 2) multiple possible outputs from a single input image. In this work, we present an approach based on disentangled representation for producing diverse outputs without paired training images. To achieve diversity, we propose to embed images onto two spaces: a domain-invariant content space capturing shared information across domains and a domain-specific attribute space. Our model takes the encoded content features extracted from a given input and the attribute vectors sampled from the attribute space to produce diverse outputs at test time. To handle unpaired training data, we introduce a novel cross-cycle consistency loss based on disentangled representations. Qualitative results show that our model can generate diverse and realistic images on a wide range of tasks without paired training data. For quantitative comparisons, we measure realism with user study and diversity with a perceptual distance metric. We apply the proposed model to domain adaptation and show competitive performance when compared to the state-of-the-art on the MNIST-M and the LineMod datasets.

1
12
下载
预览

We present new intuitions and theoretical assessments of the emergence of disentangled representation in variational autoencoders. Taking a rate-distortion theory perspective, we show the circumstances under which representations aligned with the underlying generative factors of variation of data emerge when optimising the modified ELBO bound in $\beta$-VAE, as training progresses. From these insights, we propose a modification to the training regime of $\beta$-VAE, that progressively increases the information capacity of the latent code during training. This modification facilitates the robust learning of disentangled representations in $\beta$-VAE, without the previous trade-off in reconstruction accuracy.

0
3
下载
预览

Generating novel, yet realistic, images of persons is a challenging task due to the complex interplay between the different image factors, such as the foreground, background and pose information. In this work, we aim at generating such images based on a novel, two-stage reconstruction pipeline that learns a disentangled representation of the aforementioned image factors and generates novel person images at the same time. First, a multi-branched reconstruction network is proposed to disentangle and encode the three factors into embedding features, which are then combined to re-compose the input image itself. Second, three corresponding mapping functions are learned in an adversarial manner in order to map Gaussian noise to the learned embedding feature space, for each factor respectively. Using the proposed framework, we can manipulate the foreground, background and pose of the input image, and also sample new embedding features to generate such targeted manipulations, that provide more control over the generation process. Experiments on Market-1501 and Deepfashion datasets show that our model does not only generate realistic person images with new foregrounds, backgrounds and poses, but also manipulates the generated factors and interpolates the in-between states. Another set of experiments on Market-1501 shows that our model can also be beneficial for the person re-identification task.

0
6
下载
预览
小贴士
相关资讯
人工智能 | SCI期刊专刊信息3条
Call4Papers
5+阅读 · 2019年1月10日
无监督元学习表示学习
CreateAMind
20+阅读 · 2019年1月4日
人工智能 | PRICAI 2019等国际会议信息9条
Call4Papers
4+阅读 · 2018年12月13日
disentangled-representation-papers
CreateAMind
23+阅读 · 2018年9月12日
vae 相关论文 表示学习 2
CreateAMind
6+阅读 · 2018年9月9日
vae 相关论文 表示学习 1
CreateAMind
10+阅读 · 2018年9月6日
条件GAN重大改进!cGANs with Projection Discriminator
CreateAMind
6+阅读 · 2018年2月7日
Adversarial Variational Bayes: Unifying VAE and GAN 代码
CreateAMind
7+阅读 · 2017年10月4日
Auto-Encoding GAN
CreateAMind
5+阅读 · 2017年8月4日
相关VIP内容
因果图,Causal Graphs,52页ppt
专知会员服务
144+阅读 · 2020年4月19日
专知会员服务
101+阅读 · 2020年2月1日
强化学习最新教程,17页pdf
专知会员服务
70+阅读 · 2019年10月11日
2019年机器学习框架回顾
专知会员服务
25+阅读 · 2019年10月11日
【新书】Python编程基础,669页pdf
专知会员服务
105+阅读 · 2019年10月10日
[综述]深度学习下的场景文本检测与识别
专知会员服务
41+阅读 · 2019年10月10日
机器学习入门的经验与建议
专知会员服务
45+阅读 · 2019年10月10日
【哈佛大学商学院课程Fall 2019】机器学习可解释性
专知会员服务
54+阅读 · 2019年10月9日
知识图谱本体结构构建论文合集
专知会员服务
60+阅读 · 2019年10月9日
相关论文
A Survey of Deep Learning for Scientific Discovery
Maithra Raghu,Eric Schmidt
27+阅读 · 2020年3月26日
Learning Disentangled Representations for Recommendation
Jianxin Ma,Chang Zhou,Peng Cui,Hongxia Yang,Wenwu Zhu
6+阅读 · 2019年10月31日
Knowledge Distillation from Internal Representations
Gustavo Aguilar,Yuan Ling,Yu Zhang,Benjamin Yao,Xing Fan,Edward Guo
4+阅读 · 2019年10月8日
Discovery and recognition of motion primitives in human activities
Marta Sanzari,Valsamis Ntouskos,Fiora Pirri
4+阅读 · 2019年2月4日
Ke Li,Jitendra Malik
5+阅读 · 2018年11月29日
Diverse Image-to-Image Translation via Disentangled Representations
Hsin-Ying Lee,Hung-Yu Tseng,Jia-Bin Huang,Maneesh Kumar Singh,Ming-Hsuan Yang
12+阅读 · 2018年8月2日
Christopher P. Burgess,Irina Higgins,Arka Pal,Loic Matthey,Nick Watters,Guillaume Desjardins,Alexander Lerchner
3+阅读 · 2018年4月10日
Liqian Ma,Qianru Sun,Stamatios Georgoulis,Luc Van Gool,Bernt Schiele,Mario Fritz
6+阅读 · 2018年1月21日
Top