We study the problem of designing mechanisms for trading networks that satisfy four desired properties: dominant-strategy incentive compatibility, efficiency, weak budget balance (WBB), and individual rationality (IR). Although there exist mechanisms that simultaneously satisfy these properties ex post for combinatorial auctions, we prove the impossibility that such mechanisms do not exist for a broad class of trading networks. We thus propose approaches for computing and learning the mechanisms that satisfy the four properties, in a Bayesian setting, where WBB and IR, respectively, are relaxed to ex ante and interim. For computational and sample efficiency, we introduce several techniques, including game theoretical analysis to reduce the input feature space. We empirically demonstrate that the proposed approaches successfully find the mechanisms with the four properties for those trading networks where the impossibility holds ex post.
翻译:我们研究设计贸易网络机制以满足以下四种预期特性:主要战略激励兼容性、效率、预算平衡薄弱和个别合理性(IR)的问题。虽然存在同时在组合拍卖后满足这些特性的机制,但我们证明,对于广泛的贸易网络来说,这种机制并不存在。因此,我们提出了计算和学习满足这四种特性的机制的方法,在一种巴耶斯环境下,WBB和IR分别放松了事前和临时要求。在计算和抽样效率方面,我们采用了几种技术,包括游戏理论分析,以减少投入特征空间。我们从经验上证明,所提议的方法成功地找到了那些无法在事后维持的贸易网络的四种特性的机制。