How to fairly apportion congressional seats to states has been debated for centuries. We present an alternative perspective on apportionment, centered not on states but "families" of state, sets of states with "divisor-method" quotas with the same integer part. We develop ``impartial" and ``unbiased" apportionment methods. Impartial methods apportion the same number of seats to families of states containing the same total population, whether a family consists of many small-population states or a few large-population states. Unbiased methods apportion seats so that if states are drawn repeatedly from the same distribution, the expected number of seats apportioned to each family equals the expected divisor-method quota for that family.
翻译:如何将国会席位公平分配给各州的问题已经辩论了几个世纪。 我们提出了一个关于分配的替代观点,它不是以州为中心,而是以州“家庭”为中心,由同一整数部分的“分裂-方法”配额组成的州组成。 我们开发了“公正”和“无偏见”分配方法。 公正的方法将相同数量的席位分配给拥有相同总人口的州的家庭,无论一个家庭是由许多小人口国家组成还是几个人口众多的国家组成。 不带偏见的方法分配了席位,这样,如果国家从同一分配中反复抽取,那么分配给每个家庭的预期席位数量相当于该家庭的预期分配比例。