An unambiguous and robust formulation for Wannier localization

We provide a new variational definition for the spread of an orbital under periodic boundary conditions (PBCs) that is continuous with respect to the gauge, consistent in the thermodynamic limit, well-suited to diffuse orbitals, and systematically adaptable to schemes computing localized Wannier functions. Existing definitions do not satisfy all these desiderata, partly because they depend on an "orbital center"-an ill-defined concept under PBCs. Based on this theoretical development, we showcase a robust and efficient (10x-70x fewer iterations) localization scheme across a range of materials.