Locally minimax optimal and dimension-agnostic discrete argmin inference

We revisit the discrete argmin inference problem in high-dimensional settings. Given $n$ observations from a $d$ dimensional vector, the goal is to test whether the $r$th component of the mean vector is the smallest among all components. We propose dimension-agnostic tests that maintain validity regardless of how $d$ scales with $n$, and regardless of arbitrary ties in the mean vector. Notably, our validity holds under mild moment conditions, requiring little more than finiteness of a second moment, and permitting possibly strong dependence between coordinates. In addition, we establish the local minimax separation rate for this problem, which adapts to the cardinality of a confusion set, and show that the proposed tests attain this rate. Our method uses the sample splitting and self-normalization approach of Kim and Ramdas (2024). Our tests can be easily inverted to yield confidence sets for the argmin index. Empirical results illustrate the strong performance of our approach in terms of type I error control and power compared to existing methods.