Bayes-Optimal Classifiers under Group Fairness

Machine learning algorithms are becoming integrated into more and more high-stakes decision-making processes, such as in social welfare issues. Due to the need of mitigating the potentially disparate impacts from algorithmic predictions, many approaches have been proposed in the emerging area of fair machine learning. However, the fundamental problem of characterizing Bayes-optimal classifiers under various group fairness constraints is not well understood as a theoretical benchmark. Based on the classical Neyman-Pearson argument (Neyman and Pearson, 1933; Shao, 2003) for optimal hypothesis testing, this paper provides a general framework for deriving Bayes-optimal classifiers under group fairness. This enables us to propose a group-based thresholding method that can directly control disparity, and more importantly, achieve an optimal fairness-accuracy tradeoff. These advantages are supported by experiments.