Homogeneity and Homogenizability: Hard Problems for the Logic SNP

We show that the question whether a given SNP sentence defines a homogenizable class of finite structures is undecidable, even if the sentence comes from the connected Datalog fragment and uses at most binary relation symbols. As a byproduct of our proof, we also get the undecidability of some other properties for SNP sentences, e.g., whether they can be rewritten in MMSNP, or whether they define a class with a Ramsey expansion. We subsequently show that the closely related problem of testing the amalgamation property for finitely bounded classes is EXPSPACE-hard or PSPACE-hard, depending on whether the input is specified by a universal sentence or a set of forbidden substructures.