This paper proposes a new approach for testing Granger non-causality on panel data. Instead of aggregating panel member statistics, we aggregate their corresponding p-values and show that the resulting p-value approximately bounds the type I error by the chosen significance level even if the panel members are dependent. We compare our approach against the most widely used Granger causality algorithm on panel data and show that our approach yields lower FDR at the same power for large sample sizes and panels with cross-sectional dependencies. Finally, we examine COVID-19 data about confirmed cases and deaths measured in countries/regions worldwide and show that our approach is able to discover the true causal relation between confirmed cases and deaths while state-of-the-art approaches fail.
翻译:本文件提出一种新的方法,用于测试小组数据中的Granger非因果性。我们没有汇总小组成员的对应数据,而是汇总其相应的p价值,并表明由此产生的p价值大致将I型错误与所选意义水平相联,即使小组成员是依赖的。我们比较了我们的方法与小组数据中最广泛使用的Granger因果性算法,并表明我们的方法在大型抽样规模和具有跨部门依赖性的小组中产生的FDR的功率较低。最后,我们检查了COVID-19关于全世界国家/区域经确认的病例和死亡的数据,并表明我们的方法能够发现确证案件和死亡之间的真实因果关系,而最先进的方法却失败了。