Autonomous discovery and direct instruction are two extreme sources of learning in children, but educational sciences have shown that intermediate approaches such as assisted discovery or guided play resulted in better acquisition of skills. When turning to Artificial Intelligence, the above dichotomy is translated into the distinction between autonomous agents which learn in isolation and interactive learning agents which can be taught by social partners but generally lack autonomy. In between should stand teachable autonomous agents: agents learning from both internal and teaching signals to benefit from the higher efficiency of assisted discovery. Such agents could learn on their own in the real world, but non-expert users could drive their learning behavior towards their expectations. More fundamentally, combining both capabilities might also be a key step towards general intelligence. In this paper we elucidate obstacles along this research line. First, we build on a seminal work of Bruner to extract relevant features of the assisted discovery processes. Second, we describe current research on autotelic agents, i.e. agents equipped with forms of intrinsic motivations that enable them to represent, self-generate and pursue their own goals. We argue that autotelic capabilities are paving the way towards teachable and autonomous agents. Finally, we adopt a social learning perspective on tutoring interactions and we highlight some components that are currently missing to autotelic agents before they can be taught by ordinary people using natural pedagogy, and we provide a list of specific research questions that emerge from this perspective.
翻译:自主发现和直接指导是儿童学习的两个极端来源,但教育科学表明,辅助发现或引导游戏等中间方法可以更好地获得技能。在转向人工智能时,上述二分法被转化为自主代理人与互动学习代理人之间的区别,前者孤立学习,后者可以由社会伙伴传授,但通常缺乏自主性。两者之间应当相互学习自主代理人:从内部和教学信号学习,以受益于协助发现更高的效率。这些代理人可以在现实世界中自己学习,但非专家用户可以推动他们的学习行为走向期望。更根本地说,将这两种能力结合起来可能是通向一般智能的关键一步。在本文中,我们澄清了这一研究线上的障碍。首先,我们利用布鲁纳的开创性工作来提取辅助发现过程的相关特征。第二,我们描述当前关于自学代理人的研究,即具备能够代表、自我创造和追求自身目标的内在动机的代理人。我们认为,自学能力正在为某些可传授和自主的代理人铺平道路。最后,我们从布鲁纳公司的基本研究角度,我们从一个缺失的社会学习角度,从这种缺失的代理人的角度,从一个普通的教学角度,从他们可以提供我们所缺乏的、学习的、学习的、学习的、学习的、从历史的代理人的视角,从历史角度,从历史角度,从学习的人可以提供。