Conducting causal inference with panel data is a core challenge in social science research. Advances in forecasting methods can facilitate this task by more accurately predicting the counterfactual evolution of a treated unit had treatment not occurred. In this paper, we draw on a newly developed deep neural architecture for time series forecasting (the N-BEATS algorithm). We adapt this method from conventional time series applications by incorporating leading values of control units to predict a "synthetic" untreated version of the treated unit in the post-treatment period. We refer to the estimator derived from this method as SyNBEATS, and find that it significantly outperforms traditional two-way fixed effects and synthetic control methods across a range of settings. We also find that SyNBEATS attains comparable or more accurate performance relative to more recent panel estimation methods such as matrix completion and synthetic difference in differences. Our results highlight how advances in the forecasting literature can be harnessed to improve causal inference in panel settings.
翻译:对小组数据进行因果推断是社会科学研究的一项核心挑战。预测方法的进展可以促进这项任务,更准确地预测治疗单位没有治疗的反事实演进。在本文中,我们利用新开发的深神经结构进行时间序列预测(N-BEATS算法)。我们从常规的时间序列应用中将这种方法从控制单位的主要值中调整,以预测在后处理期间处理单位的“合成”未经处理的版本。我们提到从这一方法中得出的估计器SYNBEATS, 发现它大大超越了传统的双向固定效应和合成控制方法。我们还发现SYNBEATS在一系列环境中的可比较性或更准确性能, 与最近小组估算方法相比, 如矩阵完成和合成差异的合成差异。我们的结果突出表明,如何利用预报文献的进步来改善小组环境中的因果关系。