Clio: A Hardware-Software Co-Designed Disaggregated Memory System

Memory disaggregation has attracted great attention recently because of its benefits in efficient memory utilization and ease of management. So far, memory disaggregation research has all taken one of two approaches, building/emulating memory nodes with either regular servers or raw memory devices with no processing power. The former incurs higher monetary cost and face tail latency and scalability limitations, while the latter introduce performance, security, and management problems. Server-based memory nodes and memory nodes with no processing power are two extreme approaches. We seek a sweet spot in the middle by proposing a hardware-based memory disaggregation solution that has the right amount of processing power at memory nodes. Furthermore, we take a clean-slate approach by starting from the requirements of memory disaggregation and designing a memory-disaggregation-native system. We propose a hardware-based disaggregated memory system, Clio, that virtualizes and manages disaggregated memory at the memory node. Clio includes a new hardware-based virtual memory system, a customized network system, and a framework for computation offloading. In building Clio, we not only co-design OS functionalities, hardware architecture, and the network system, but also co-design the compute node and memory node. We prototyped Clio's memory node with FPGA and implemented its client-node functionalities in a user-space library. Clio achieves 100 Gbps throughput and an end-to-end latency of 2.5 us at median and 3.2 us at the 99th percentile. Clio scales much better and has orders of magnitude lower tail latency than RDMA, and it has 1.1x to 3.4x energy saving compared to CPU-based and SmartNIC-based disaggregated memory systems and is 2.7x faster than software-based SmartNIC solutions.