In this note, we introduce a distributed twist on the classic coupon collector problem: a set of $m$ collectors wish to each obtain a set of $n$ coupons; for this, they can each sample coupons uniformly at random, but can also meet in pairwise interactions, during which they can exchange coupons. By doing so, they hope to reduce the number of coupons that must be sampled by each collector in order to obtain a full set. This extension is natural when considering real-world manifestations of the coupon collector phenomenon, and has been remarked upon and studied empirically [Hayes and Hannigan 2006, Ahmad et al. 2014, Delmarcelle 2019]. We provide the first theoretical analysis for such a scenario. We find that "coupon collecting with friends" can indeed significantly reduce the number of coupons each collector must sample, and raises interesting connections to the more traditional variants of the problem. While our analysis is in most cases asymptotically tight, there are several open questions raised, regarding finer-grained analysis of both "coupon collecting with friends", and of a long-studied variant of the original problem in which a collector requires multiple full sets of coupons.
翻译:在本说明中,我们引入了对经典的优惠券收藏者问题的分布式扭曲:一组以百万美元计的收藏家希望每人获得一套美元优惠券;为此,他们可以任意地将每套票券样本集中起来,但也可以进行对称互动,这样他们可以交换票券。他们希望减少每个收藏家为获得全套票而必须抽样的优惠券数量。在考虑优惠券收藏者现象的真实世界表现时,这一扩展是自然的,并且已经用经验方式[Hayes和Hannigan,2006年;Ahmad等人,2014年;Delmarcelle,2019]来评论和研究。我们为这种情景提供了第一种理论分析。我们发现“与朋友一起收集”确实可以大大减少每个收藏者必须抽样的优惠券数量,并且与更传统的问题变体产生有趣的联系。虽然我们的分析在多数情况下是暂时紧凑的,但是就精细分析“与朋友一起收集”以及长期研究的原始问题的变体提出了几个开放的问题,即关于精细分析“与朋友一起收集”以及需要多个收藏家进行多重的组合的原始问题。