We show that the theorems in Hansen (2021a) (the version accepted by Econometrica), except for one, are not new as they coincide with classical theorems like the good old Gauss-Markov or Aitken Theorem, respectively; the exceptional theorem is incorrect. Hansen (2021b) corrects this theorem. As a result, all theorems in the latter version coincide with the above mentioned classical theorems. Furthermore, we also show that the theorems in Hansen (2022) (the version forthcoming in Econometrica) either coincide with the classical theorems just mentioned, or contain extra assumptions that are alien to the Gauss-Markov or Aitken Theorem.
翻译:我们显示,汉森(2021年a)的理论(Economica(Economica)所接受的版本),除其中之一外,并非新理论,因为它们与古典理论(分别为古老的高斯-马尔科夫或艾特肯理论)重合;例外的理论是不正确的。汉森(2021年b)纠正了这个理论。因此,后一个版本的所有理论都与上述古典理论重合。此外,我们还显示汉森(2022年)(即将在Economica中出现的版本)的理论要么与刚才提到的古典理论重合,要么包含与高斯-马尔科夫或艾特肯理论无关的额外假设。