We provide novel simple representations of strategy-proof voting rules when voters have uni-dimensional single-peaked preferences (as well as multi-dimensional separable preferences). The analysis recovers, links and unifies existing results in the literature such as Moulin's classic characterization in terms of phantom voters and Barber\`a, Gul and Stacchetti's in terms of winning coalitions ("generalized median voter schemes"). First, we compare the computational properties of the various representations and show that the grading curve representation is superior in terms of computational complexity. Moreover, the new approach allows us to obtain new characterizations when strategy-proofness is combined with other desirable properties such as anonymity, responsiveness, ordinality, participation, consistency, or proportionality. In the anonymous case, two methods are single out: the -- well know -- ordinal median and the -- most recent -- linear median.
翻译:当选民有单维单一和单维的偏好(以及多维分立的偏好)时,我们提供了战略上可行的投票规则的新颖简单表述。 分析恢复、链接并统一了穆林在文献中的现有结果,例如莫林在幻影选民和巴尔贝拉、古尔和斯塔切蒂在赢得联盟方面的典型特征(“通用中位选民计划”)。首先,我们比较了各种代表的计算属性,并表明分级曲线在计算复杂性方面代表的优势。 此外,新的方法使我们能够在战略的可校准性与匿名、响应性、适切性、参与性、一致性或相称性等其他可取的属性相结合时获得新的特征。 在匿名的情况下,有两种方法被单独列出: -- 清楚知道 -- -- 或最接近的中位和 -- -- 最新的 -- -- 线性中位。