We report on a series of experiments in which we study the coevolutionary "arms-race" dynamics among groups of agents that engage in adaptive automated trading in an accurate model of contemporary financial markets. At any one time, every trader in the market is trying to make as much profit as possible given the current distribution of different other trading strategies that it finds itself pitched against in the market; but the distribution of trading strategies and their observable behaviors is constantly changing, and changes in any one trader are driven to some extent by the changes in all the others. Prior studies of coevolutionary dynamics in markets have concentrated on systems where traders can choose one of a small number of fixed pure strategies, and can change their choice occasionally, thereby giving a market with a discrete phase-space, made up of a finite set of possible system states. Here we present first results from two independent sets of experiments, where we use minimal-intelligence trading-agents but in which the space of possible strategies is continuous and hence infinite. Our work reveals that by taking only a small step in the direction of increased realism we move immediately into high-dimensional phase-spaces, which then present difficulties in visualising and understanding the coevolutionary dynamics unfolding within the system. We conclude that further research is required to establish better analytic tools for monitoring activity and progress in co-adapting markets. We have released relevant Python code as open-source on GitHub, to enable others to continue this work.
翻译:我们报告了一系列实验,我们在这个实验中研究在当代金融市场的准确模型中从事适应性自动化交易的各类代理人之间的“武器-武器-武器-竞赛”动态。在任何一个时刻,市场中的每个贸易商都试图尽可能多地赚取利润,因为目前分布着不同的其他贸易战略,而市场中发现它们与市场相对应;但是,贸易战略的分布及其可观察行为正在不断变化,任何一个交易商的变化在某种程度上都受到其他所有交易商变化的驱动。以前对市场中共同革命动态的研究集中在贸易商可以选择少数固定的纯战略之一并偶尔改变其选择的系统上,从而给市场一个离散的阶段空间,由有限的一套可能的系统状态组成。我们在这里介绍两套独立实验的第一个结果,即我们使用最小的智能交易代理商,但任何可能的战略的空间都是持续和无限的。我们的工作显示,通过在更大的现实主义方向上迈出一小步,我们就可以立即进入高层次的工作-阶段空间,从而给市场带来一个不相干的空间,从而在不断推进的动态中建立一个更好的动态活动。我们在这里展示了目前需要的动态研究的工具,从而形成一种视觉上的困难。