One objection to conventional AI ethics is that it slows innovation. This presentation responds by reconfiguring ethics as an innovation accelerator. The critical elements develop from a contrast between Stability AI's Diffusion and OpenAI's Dall-E. By analyzing the divergent values underlying their opposed strategies for development and deployment, five conceptions are identified as common to acceleration ethics. Uncertainty is understood as positive and encouraging, rather than discouraging. Innovation is conceived as intrinsically valuable, instead of worthwhile only as mediated by social effects. AI problems are solved by more AI, not less. Permissions and restrictions governing AI emerge from a decentralized process, instead of a unified authority. The work of ethics is embedded in AI development and application, instead of functioning from outside. Together, these attitudes and practices remake ethics as provoking rather than restraining artificial intelligence.
翻译:常规的人工智能伦理面临的一个反对意见是它会减缓创新速度。本文的回应是重新构建伦理作为一种创新加速器。其中的关键要素源于稳定人工智能的扩散和OpenAI的Dall-E之间的对比。通过分析它们对开发和部署的不同策略背后的不同价值观,我们将五个概念确定为加速伦理的共同构件。这些概念包括:不确定性被看作是积极的、鼓励的,而不是阻碍的;创新被认为是内在有价值的,而不仅仅是通过社会效应来证明其价值;解决AI问题的方法是更多的AI,而不是更少;授权和限制AI的出现应该来自于分散的过程,而不是统一的权威。伦理学的工作是嵌入在AI的开发和应用中,而不是从外部发挥作用。总的来说,这些态度和做法将伦理完全重塑为一种推动人工智能进步的力量,而不是制约它的力量。