The current systematic review includes a comprehensive 3-tier strategy (manual search, backward snowballing, and database search). The accuracy of the search methodology has been analyzed in terms of extracting related studies and collecting comprehensive and complete information in a supplementary file. In the search methodology, qualitative criteria have been defined to select studies with the highest quality and the most relevant among all search spaces. Also, some queries have been created using important keywords in the field under study in order to find studies related to the field of the cloud broker. Out of 1928 extracted search spaces, 171 search spaces have been selected based on defined quality criteria. Then, 1298 studies have been extracted from the selected search spaces and have been selected 496 high-quality papers published in prestigious journals, conferences, and workshops that the advent of them have been from 2009 until the end of 2019. In Systematic Mapping Study (SMS), 8 research questions have been designed to achieve goals such as identifying the most important and hottest topics in the field of cloud broker, identifying existing trends and issues, identifying active researchers and countries in the cloud broker field, a variety of commonly used techniques in building cloud brokers, variety of evaluation methods, the amount of research conducted in this field by year and place of publication and the identification of the most important active search spaces.
翻译:目前系统审查包括一项综合性的三级战略(人工搜索、后雪球和数据库搜索),对搜索方法的准确性进行了分析,从相关研究的摘录和收集全面完整资料的角度对搜索方法的准确性进行了分析;在搜索方法中,确定了质量标准,以在所有搜索空间中选择质量最高和最相关的研究;此外,还利用研究领域的重要关键词创建了一些查询,以便找到与云介质领域有关的研究;在1928年抽取的搜索空间中,171个搜索空间是根据确定的质量标准选定的;随后,从选定的搜索空间提取了1298项研究,并选定了在著名期刊、会议和讲习班上发表的496份高质量文件,这些文件的出现时间是2009年至2019年底;在系统绘图研究中,设计了8个研究问题,目的是实现以下目标:确定云介质领域最重要和最热点的专题,确定现有趋势和问题,确定云介质领域的活跃研究人员和国家,在建设云介质中常用的各种技术,评估方法的种类,积极研究空间的确定,以及这一领域的重要搜索地点。