The experience shows that cooperating and communicating computing systems, comprising segregated single processors, have severe performance limitations. In his classic "First Draft" von Neumann warned that using a "too fast processor" vitiates his simple "procedure" (but not his computing model!); furthermore, that using the classic computing paradigm for imitating neuronal operations, is unsound. Amdahl added that large machines, comprising many processors, have an inherent disadvantage. Given that ANN's components are heavily communicating with each other, they are built from a large number of components designed/fabricated for use in conventional computing, furthermore they attempt to mimic biological operation using improper technological solutions, their achievable payload computing performance is conceptually modest. The type of workload that AI-based systems generate leads to an exceptionally low payload computational performance, and their design/technology limits their size to just above the "toy" level systems: the scaling of processor-based ANN systems is strongly nonlinear. Given the proliferation and growing size of ANN systems, we suggest ideas to estimate in advance the efficiency of the device or application. Through analyzing published measurements we provide evidence that the role of data transfer time drastically influences both ANNs performance and feasibility. It is discussed how some major theoretical limiting factors, ANN's layer structure and their methods of technical implementation of communication affect their efficiency. The paper starts from von Neumann's original model, without neglecting the transfer time apart from processing time; derives an appropriate interpretation and handling for Amdahl's law. It shows that, in that interpretation, Amdahl's Law correctly describes ANNs.
翻译:经验表明,由隔离的单一处理器组成的合作和通信计算系统存在严重的性能限制。在经典的“第一稿”冯纽曼的经典“第一稿”中,诺伊曼警告说,使用“太快处理器”会破坏他简单的“程序”(但不是他的计算模型 ) ; 此外,使用典型的计算模式模拟神经操作,是不可靠的。 阿姆达尔补充说,由许多处理器组成的大型机器具有内在的劣势。鉴于ANNE的部件相互之间有很强的沟通,因此它们是由大量设计/制造用于常规计算机的部件建造的,此外,它们试图利用不适当的技术解决方案模拟生物操作,其可实现的有效载荷计算性能在概念上是微不足道的。 AI系统产生的工作量导致极低的计算性能,而其设计/技术将其规模限制在仅仅高于“玩具”级系统之上:基于处理器的ANNE系统的规模非常不直线性。鉴于ANNE系统的扩散和日益扩大,我们建议用各种想法来估计设备或应用的效率。通过分析所公布的测量的时间,我们通过分析,我们所提供的有效计算结果表明,ANNEL的准确的计算结果是如何影响了它们的实际效率。