On the first-order transduction quasiorder of hereditary classes of graphs

We study various aspects of the first-order transduction quasi-order, which provides a way of measuring the relative complexity of classes of structures based on whether one can encode the other using a formula of first-order (FO) logic. In contrast with the conjectured simplicity of the transduction quasi-order for monadic second-order logic, the FO-transduction quasi-order is very complex; in particular, we prove that the quotient partial order is not a lattice, although it is a bounded distributive join-semilattice, as is the subposet of additive classes. Many standard properties from structural graph theory and model theory naturally appear in this quasi-order. For example, we characterize transductions of paths, cubic graphs, and cubic trees in terms of bandwidth, bounded degree, and treewidth. We establish that the classes of all graphs with pathwidth at most~$k$, for $k\geq 1$, form a strict hierarchy in the FO-transduction quasi-order and leave open whether same is true for treewidth. This leads to considering whether properties admit maximum or minimum classes in this quasi-order. We prove that many properties do not admit a maximum class, and that star forests are the minimum class that is not a transduction of a class with bounded degree, which can be seen as an instance of transduction duality. We close with a notion of dense analogues of sparse classes, and discuss several related conjectures. As a ubiquitous tool in our results, we prove a normal form for FO-transductions that manifests the locality of FO logic. This is among several other technical results about FO-transductions which we anticipate being broadly useful.