Political organizations worldwide keep innovating their use of social media technologies. Here, we document a novel configuration of technologies and organizational forms used to manipulate Twitter trends in the 2019 Indian general election. The organizers rely on an extensive network of WhatsApp groups to coordinate mass-postings by loosely affiliated political supporters. To investigate the campaigns, we joined more than 600 political WhatsApp groups that support the Bharatiya Janata Party, the right-wing party that won the general election. We found direct evidence of 75 hashtag manipulation campaigns, including mobilization messages and lists of pre-written tweets. We estimate the campaigns' size and whether they succeeded in creating controlled social media narratives. We show that the campaigns are smaller than what media reports suggest; still, they reliably produce Twitter trends drawing on the voices of loosely affiliated supporters. Centrally controlled but voluntary in participation, this novel configuration of a campaign complicates the debates over the legitimate use of digital tools for political participation. It may have provided a blueprint for participatory media manipulation by a party with popular support.
翻译:世界各地的政治组织不断创新使用社交媒体技术。在这里,我们记录了印度2019年大选中用于操纵推特趋势的技术和组织形式的新组合。组织者依靠一个庞大的“WhessApp”团体网络来协调松散的政治支持者的群众布局。为了调查这些运动,我们加入了支持赢得大选的右翼政党“Bharatiya Janata党”的600多个政治“WhesApp”团体。我们发现了75个标签操纵运动的直接证据,包括动员信息和预写推文清单。我们估计了这些运动的规模以及它们是否成功地创造了受控制的社交媒体叙事。我们显示,这些运动的规模小于媒体报道所显示的内容;它们仍然可靠地利用松散支持者的声音制作了“Twitter”趋势。中央控制但自愿参与的这一运动新组合使得关于合法使用数字工具参与政治参与的辩论复杂化。它可能为一个得到民众支持的政党的参与性媒体操纵提供了蓝图。