Optimal selection of the starting lineup for a football team

The success of a football team depends on various individual skills and performances of the selected players as well as how cohesively they perform. This work proposes a two-stage process for selecting optimal playing eleven of a football team from its pool of available players. In the first stage, for the reference team, a LASSO-induced modified trinomial logistic regression model is derived to analyze the probabilities of the three possible outcomes. The model takes into account strengths of the players in the team as well as those of the opponent, home advantage, and also the effects of individual players and player combinations beyond the recorded performances of these players. Careful use of the LASSO technique acts as an appropriate enabler of the player selection exercise while keeping the number of variables at a reasonable level. Then, in the second stage, a GRASP-type meta-heuristic is implemented for the team selection which maximizes the probability of win for the team. The work is illustrated with English Premier League data from 2008/09 to 2015/16. The application demonstrates that the model in the first stage furnishes valuable insights about the deciding factors for different teams whereas the optimization steps can be effectively used to determine the best possible starting lineup under various circumstances. Based on the adopted model and methodology, we propose a measure of efficiency in team selection by the team management and analyze the performance of EPL teams on this front.