Blockchain has been increasingly used as a software component to enable decentralisation in software architecture for a variety of applications. Blockchain governance has received considerable attention to ensure the safe and appropriate use and evolution of blockchain, especially after the Ethereum DAO attack in 2016. However, there are no systematic efforts to analyse existing governance solutions. To understand the state-of-the-art of blockchain governance, we conducted a systematic literature review with 35 primary studies. The extracted data from primary studies are synthesised to answer identified research questions. The study results reveal several major findings: 1) governance can improve the adaptability and upgradability of blockchain, whilst the current studies neglect broader ethical responsibilities as the objectives of blockchain governance; 2) governance is along with the development process of a blockchain platform, while ecosystem-level governance process is missing, and; 3) the responsibilities and capabilities of blockchain stakeholders are briefly discussed, whilst the decision rights, accountability, and incentives of blockchain stakeholders are still under studied. We provide actionable guidelines for academia and practitioners to use throughout the lifecycle of blockchain, and identify future trends to support researchers in this area.
翻译:供应链治理受到很大关注,以确保安全、适当地使用和逐步发展块块链,特别是在2016年Etheum DAO袭击之后;然而,没有系统地努力分析现有的治理解决方案。为了了解块链治理的最新技术,我们进行了系统化的文献审查,共进行了35项初级研究。从初级研究中提取的数据经过综合,以解答已确定的研究问题。研究结果揭示了若干主要结论:(1) 治理可以改善块链的适应性和升级性,而目前的研究忽视了作为块链治理目标的更广泛的道德责任;(2) 治理与块链平台的发展进程同时存在,而生态系统层面的治理进程则缺失;(3) 简要讨论了块链利益攸关方的责任和能力,同时仍在研究链利益攸关方的决策权、问责制和激励措施。我们为学术界和从业人员提供了在块链整个生命周期内使用的行动指南,并确定了支持该领域研究人员的未来趋势。