In recent years, there has been a stimulating discussion on how artificial intelligence (AI) can support the science and engineering of intelligent educational applications. Many studies in the field are proposing actionable data mining pipelines and machine-learning models driven by learning-related data. The potential of these pipelines and models to amplify unfairness for certain categories of students is however receiving increasing attention. If AI applications are to have a positive impact on education, it is crucial that their design considers fairness at every step. Through anonymous surveys and interviews with experts (researchers and practitioners) who have published their research at top-tier educational conferences in the last year, we conducted the first expert-driven systematic investigation on the challenges and needs for addressing fairness throughout the development of educational systems based on AI. We identified common and diverging views about the challenges and the needs faced by educational technologies experts in practice, that lead the community to have a clear understanding on the main questions raising doubts in this topic. Based on these findings, we highlighted directions that will facilitate the ongoing research towards fairer AI for education.
翻译:近年来,人们就人工智能(AI)如何支持智能教育应用的科学和工程学进行了热烈的讨论,许多实地研究正在提出由学习相关数据驱动的可操作的数据挖掘管道和机器学习模式。这些管道和模式有可能扩大某些类别学生的不公平程度,但这种潜力正在日益受到重视。如果AI应用对教育产生积极的影响,那么它们的设计就必须考虑每一个步骤的公平性。通过匿名调查和采访在去年最高级教育会议上发表研究成果的专家(研究人员和从业人员),我们首次进行了专家驱动的系统调查,探讨在根据AI发展整个教育系统过程中解决公平问题的挑战和需要。我们查明了对教育技术专家在实践中面临的挑战和需要的共同和不同看法,这些看法使社区对引起怀疑的主要问题有明确的了解。根据这些调查结果,我们着重指出了将促进当前研究的方向,以便实现更公平的教育AI。