Clinical trials are the basis of Evidence-Based Medicine. Trial results are reviewed by experts and consensus panels for producing meta-analyses and clinical practice guidelines. However, reviewing these results is a long and tedious task, hence the meta-analyses and guidelines are not updated each time a new trial is published. Moreover, the independence of experts may be difficult to appraise. On the contrary, in many other domains, including medical risk analysis, the advent of data science, big data and visual analytics allowed moving from expert-based to fact-based knowledge. Since 12 years, many trial results are publicly available online in trial registries. Nevertheless, data science methods have not yet been applied widely to trial data. In this paper, we present a platform for analyzing the safety events reported during clinical trials and published in trial registries. This platform is based on an ontological model including 582 trials on pain treatments, and uses semantic web technologies for querying this dataset at various levels of granularity. It also relies on a 26-dimensional flower glyph for the visualization of the Adverse Drug Events (ADE) rates in 13 categories and 2 levels of seriousness. We illustrate the interest of this platform through several use cases and we were able to find back conclusions that were initially found during meta-analyses. The platform was presented to four experts in drug safety, and is publicly available online, with the ontology of pain treatment ADE.
翻译:临床试验是基于证据的医学的基础。试验结果由专家和协商一致小组审查,以编制元分析和临床实践准则。但是,审查这些结果是一项漫长而繁琐的任务,因此,在每次公布新的试验时,没有更新元分析和准则。此外,专家的独立性可能难以评估。相反,在许多其他领域,包括医疗风险分析、数据科学的出现、大数据和视觉分析学,允许从专家知识向事实知识转变。自12年以来,许多试验结果在试验登记册上公开提供。然而,数据科学方法尚未广泛应用于试验数据。在本文件中,我们提出了一个平台,用于分析临床试验期间和在试验登记册中报告的安全事件。这个平台基于一种肿瘤模型,包括582次疼痛治疗试验,以及使用语义网络技术在不同阶段查询这一数据集。它还依靠26度的花粉,在试验登记册中,许多试验结果在网上公布。然而,数据科学方法尚未被广泛应用于试验数据。在13类临床试验和试验登记册中公布。这个平台以公开分析安全事件的速度和2级。我们从4次在线研究中发现,在公开分析中发现,在4个实验中发现,在4级和2级的药物分析中发现,在4级中发现,在4级和4级的实验中发现了。在4级中发现,在4级的实验中发现了。我们发现,在4级和4级的实验中发现,在4级的实验中发现,在4级的实验中发现了。在4级和2级的实验中发现了。在4级中发现,在4级的实验中发现,在4级的实验中发现,在4级的实验。在4级的实验。在4级的实验中发现,在4级的实验。在4级的实验中发现,在4级的实验中发现,在4级的实验中发现,在4级的实验中发现,在4级中发现,在4级和2级中发现了。